How to Pick the Right Health Plan for 2027: A Step-by-Step Guide

Older couple at a table at home reviewing a phone and paperwork together as they choose a health plan

HealthCare.gov lists the monthly premium first, so most people use it to choose a health plan. That makes sense. It’s the biggest number on the screen, and you’ll pay it every month. But the plan with the lowest premium often isn’t the plan that costs the least over a full year. Here’s a seven-step way to choose a health plan with the shopping page open in another tab.

This year, the stakes are higher. Nationally, KFF found that benchmark Silver premiums, which set subsidy amounts, rose about 13% for 2027. That’s the second straight double-digit increase. KFF also found the average Marketplace deductible grew about $1,000 per person in 2026. More enrollees shifted to higher-deductible plans, and some gave up savings they qualified for.

Think of this as the companion to our 2027 open enrollment guide for Utahns. That post covers dates, eligibility, and the full income chart. This one covers how to actually choose.

Step 1: Estimate Your 2027 Income

Everything downstream depends on this number. The Marketplace uses modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) for your whole tax household, projected for 2027. MAGI is the adjusted gross income on your tax return, plus a few add-backs. If you’re self-employed, use your expected net business income, after expenses.

A bad estimate costs more than it used to. Starting with the 2026 tax year, there’s no cap on repaying excess subsidy. Our post on why your income estimate is now more expensive to get wrong explains how that works.

There’s also a planning lever most people never hear about. Deductible contributions to a health savings account (HSA), SEP-IRA, solo 401(k), or traditional IRA lower your MAGI. That can raise your premium tax credit. The federal poverty level (FPL) is an income guideline based on household size. If you’re near 250% of FPL, a contribution could decide whether you qualify for the savings in Step 2. KFF’s open enrollment analysis flags the same point.

Treat this as a question for your CPA, not for us. Eligibility and limits depend on your situation, and HSA contributions require an HSA-eligible plan.

Step 2: Find Out If You Qualify for Cost-Sharing Reductions

This is the most valuable item on the shopping page, and the least understood. Cost-sharing reductions (CSRs) lower your deductible, copays, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximum. They add nothing to your premium.

You qualify if your household income is between 100% and 250% FPL and you enroll in a Silver plan. You also need to be eligible for the premium tax credit. HealthCare.gov’s page on cost-sharing reductions is clear: these savings come only with Silver plans. Buy Bronze to save on premium, and you give them up entirely.

CSRs raise a plan’s actuarial value, the average share of covered medical costs a plan pays. A standard Silver plan pays about 70%. With CSRs, it pays about:

  • 94% at 100% to 150% FPL: up to $23,940 for one person or $49,500 for a family of four
  • 87% at over 150% to 200% FPL: up to $31,920 for one person or $66,000 for a family of four
  • 73% at over 200% to 250% FPL: up to $39,900 for one person or $82,500 for a family of four

These figures use the 2026 poverty guidelines, which apply to 2027 coverage. In Utah, most adults under roughly 138% FPL are directed to Medicaid instead. Our open enrollment guide has the full chart for every household size.

Notice the top level. At 94%, a Silver plan pays a larger share of costs than a Platinum plan would. You’ll see the reduced amounts in the Silver plan details once your application shows you qualify.

Here’s how the metal tiers compare. The CSR row is the one most shoppers have never seen.

Plan categoryApproximate actuarial valueTends to fitCost-sharing reductions?
BronzeAbout 60%Rare care users with savings for a high deductibleNo
SilverAbout 70%Moderate users who want middle premiums and costsOnly tier that qualifies
Silver with CSRsAbout 73%, 87%, or 94%Households from 100% to 250% FPLYes, at no added premium
GoldAbout 80%Regular care users who want lower costs per visitNo
PlatinumAbout 90%Heavy care users; limited availability in UtahNo
Approximate values based on HealthCare.gov’s plan categories. Actual plans and county availability vary.

Step 3: Compare Total Yearly Cost, Not Monthly Premium

This step changes how you choose a health plan. Your real yearly cost is twelve months of premium plus what you spend on care. That second part depends on the deductible, copays, and coinsurance. The deductible is what you pay before the plan starts sharing costs.

Here’s a hypothetical example. Two plans $200 a month apart are $2,400 apart over a year. If the cheaper plan’s deductible is $4,000 higher, one hospital stay can erase that savings and more.

So run each plan you’re considering through two scenarios:

  • A light year: twelve months of premium, plus a few routine visits and any regular prescriptions.
  • A heavy year: twelve months of premium, plus the out-of-pocket maximum. That’s your worst case for covered, in-network care.

The right plan is usually the one you can live with in both years. For a quick first pass, select “Add yearly cost” on HealthCare.gov and pick a low, medium, or high level of care. HealthCare.gov’s own guide to picking a plan stresses weighing both kinds of costs.

Step 4: Check the Out-of-Pocket Maximum

This number defines your worst case, and almost nobody checks it. The deductible is the first slice of costs you pay yourself. The out-of-pocket maximum is the most you’ll pay for covered, in-network care in a year, deductible included. Premiums don’t count toward it.

For 2027, federal rules cap it at $12,000 for one person and $24,000 for a family. Many plans set theirs lower. CSRs cut the cap to $4,000 for one person up to 200% FPL. From 200% to 250% FPL, the cap is $9,600. That protection is a big reason Step 2 matters.

Out-of-network care usually doesn’t count toward the maximum, which leads to the next step.

Step 5: Verify Your Doctors Are in Network

A plan’s network is the group of doctors, hospitals, and clinics it contracts with. HealthCare.gov lets you add your doctors as you compare plans. Treat that as a starting point, not the final word.

Call each provider’s office. Ask whether they’re contracted with that specific plan for 2027, not just the insurer. One insurer can sell plans with different networks, so give the office the exact plan name.

This matters more in parts of Utah where networks are narrower. If you travel or split time out of state, ask about out-of-area coverage. Many HMO and EPO plans cover out-of-network care only in emergencies. Our Marketplace health insurance team checks networks plan by plan.

Step 6: Check Your Prescriptions

Each plan publishes a formulary, its list of covered drugs. Add your medications on HealthCare.gov as you compare, then confirm each one on the insurer’s formulary.

Check the tier, too. Formularies sort drugs into tiers, and the tier sets your copay or coinsurance. A plan can cover a drug and still make it expensive. Finally, confirm your pharmacy is preferred in that plan, because preferred and standard pricing can differ meaningfully.

Step 7: Make the Choice on Purpose

If you do nothing, HealthCare.gov generally re-enrolls you in your current plan at next year’s price. It also keeps your old income on file. Our post on whether Marketplace plans renew automatically explains the risk. Don’t let a default choose a health plan for you.

Choose by December 15 for coverage that starts January 1. Open enrollment closes January 15.

When the Lowest Premium Is the Right Call

Sometimes the cheapest premium is the right answer. Picture someone above 250% FPL who rarely sees a doctor and takes no regular prescriptions. They also have savings that could cover a deductible. For that person, Bronze is a perfectly rational way to choose a health plan.

Bronze has another plus. HealthCare.gov says all Bronze plans now work with an HSA, a tax-advantaged account for medical costs. A few other honest caveats apply to this whole method:

  • A higher premium doesn’t guarantee better coverage. Plans in the same tier can differ in network, formulary, and service. The tier shows how costs are split, not whether a plan is good.
  • Cash flow is real. The plan with the lowest yearly cost may still strain your monthly budget. This method doesn’t dismiss that. It shows you what you’re trading.
  • Nobody can predict their medical year. Testing a light year and a heavy year won’t remove the guesswork. It helps you pick a plan you can live with either way.

Common Questions When You Choose a Health Plan

Is Bronze or Silver better?

Neither is better for everyone. Between 100% and 250% of the federal poverty level, only Silver comes with cost-sharing reductions. Above that range, Bronze can make sense if you rarely use care and could cover a high deductible. Compare total yearly cost for a light year and a heavy year.

What is a cost-sharing reduction?

It’s a discount that lowers your deductible, copays, coinsurance, and out-of-pocket maximum at no added premium. It comes only with Silver plans. You qualify with household income between 100% and 250% of the federal poverty level, if you’re also eligible for a premium tax credit.

How do I know if my doctor is in network?

Add your doctors on HealthCare.gov while you compare plans, then call each office. Ask whether they’re contracted with the exact plan, by name, for 2027. Networks can differ between plans from the same insurer.

What’s the difference between a deductible and an out-of-pocket maximum?

The deductible is what you pay for covered care before your plan starts sharing costs. The out-of-pocket maximum is the most you’ll pay in a year for covered, in-network care, deductible included. Once you reach it, the plan pays 100% of covered costs for the rest of the year.

Should I pick the cheapest plan?

Sometimes. A low premium can work if your income is above 250% of the federal poverty level, you use little care, and you have savings for the deductible. If you qualify for cost-sharing reductions, choosing Bronze means giving them up. Compare total yearly cost, not just the premium.

Want a Second Set of Eyes Before You Choose a Health Plan?

Worked in order, these seven steps take about an hour. Start with your income and CSRs, then compare total cost, networks, and drugs before you commit.

Still, if you’re thinking, “This is more work than I expected,” you’re right. It’s tedious to do alone, and it’s exactly what a broker does all day. We’ll check whether you qualify for cost-sharing reductions. We’ll confirm your doctors and prescriptions under each plan you’re considering. And we’ll compare each option in a light year and a heavy year, not just per month.

It costs you nothing, and if your current plan is already the right one, we’ll tell you. Book a time with us before December 15 for coverage that starts January 1. For options beyond the Marketplace, see our health insurance services.

Disclosure: Groberg Insurance Advisors is a licensed independent insurance agency in Utah. We are not tax advisors, and nothing here is tax advice, including the discussion of deductible contributions and MAGI. Premium tax credit and cost-sharing reduction eligibility depend on household income, household size, age, and location, and can only be determined through an application. Plan availability, networks, formularies, premiums, and cost-sharing vary by plan and county and are subject to change. Dollar figures in the total-cost example are hypothetical. This is an advertisement and a solicitation for insurance.